Before June 2018, a state could only force a business to collect its sales tax if the business had a physical presence there — a store, a warehouse, employees. Then the Supreme Court decided South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., throwing out the physical-presence rule and holding that a state may require out-of-state sellers to collect sales tax based on economic activity alone. Within two years, nearly every state with a sales tax had adopted an economic-nexus law. The result is that a business shipping products or delivering taxable services nationwide can be obligated to register, collect, and remit in dozens of states without ever setting foot in them.
The thresholds sound tidy — the South Dakota law the Court upheld used $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions — but the reality is a patchwork. States picked different dollar figures, some kept the transaction count and some scrapped it, and they measure the look-back period differently. Marketplace-facilitator laws add another layer: Amazon, Etsy, and Walmart usually collect on your behalf, but those sales can still push you over a threshold that makes your own website sales taxable. The businesses that get burned are the ones that assumed "we're small" or "the marketplace handles it" and never checked. Because uncollected sales tax becomes the seller's personal liability, the cost of guessing wrong lands squarely on you.
What Wayfair changed
The old rule, set by Quill Corp. v. North Dakota in 1992, was that a state could not require a mail-order or online seller to collect sales tax without physical presence. As e-commerce grew, states argued they were losing billions in tax on remote sales. In Wayfair, the Court agreed that the physical-presence rule was "unsound and incorrect," and upheld South Dakota's law as a reasonable substitute.
Before Wayfair (Quill, 1992)
- Physical presence required to force collection
- Out-of-state online sellers often collected nothing
- Buyers technically owed 'use tax' but rarely paid it
- States lost significant revenue on remote sales
- Compliance burden fell only where you had a footprint
After Wayfair (2018)
- Sales volume alone can require collection
- Nearly every sales-tax state adopted economic nexus
- Remote sellers must register in each qualifying state
- Marketplace-facilitator laws shifted much collection to platforms
- Compliance can span dozens of states at once
The core shift: nexus for sales-tax purposes is now about how much you sell into a state, not whether you have people or property there. Every seller doing meaningful interstate volume has to think about compliance in states it may never visit.
The thresholds vary — that's the whole problem
There is no single national threshold. States started from the South Dakota model and then diverged. Some kept $100,000, others moved to $500,000; some retained the 200-transaction count, and a growing number repealed it because it swept in tiny sellers with many low-dollar orders. The measurement window also differs — current year, prior calendar year, or a rolling twelve months.
| Threshold model | How it works | Watch-out |
|---|---|---|
| $100,000 or 200 transactions | Nexus if you exceed either one | 200 small orders can trip it before you hit $100k |
| $100,000 only | Transaction count removed | Simpler, but the dollar figure still applies per state |
| $500,000 in sales | Higher bar used by some large states | Easy to overlook that other states sit far lower |
| Prior or current year | Some states test the prior year, some the current | You may cross mid-year and owe from that point forward |
Because the rules differ state by state, the only reliable approach is to track your sales by ship-to state and compare each running total against that state's specific threshold. A spreadsheet works when you sell into a few states; sales-tax automation software becomes worth it once you cross into many.
Marketplace facilitators — help and a hidden catch
Marketplace-facilitator laws require platforms like Amazon, Etsy, eBay, and Walmart to collect and remit sales tax on the sales they facilitate. For a seller who only sells through those platforms, this removes most of the collection burden. But two catches trip people up.
Even though the marketplace collects the tax, most states count your marketplace sales toward your economic-nexus threshold. So if you sell $90,000 through Amazon and $20,000 through your own Shopify store into a state, your combined $110,000 can put you over the line — meaning you must register and collect on the Shopify sales yourself, even though Amazon already handled its portion. Always confirm whether a state includes or excludes marketplace sales when measuring nexus.
The second catch is direct sales through your own site. The marketplace only covers what it facilitates. Any channel you run yourself — your website, phone orders, wholesale — is entirely your responsibility to track and remit once you have nexus.
How to get compliant
Getting right with sales tax is a defined sequence, and doing it in order keeps you from collecting tax you have no authority to collect (a problem of its own) or remitting to the wrong state.
Measure your nexus footprint
Pull sales by ship-to state for the current and prior year. Compare each state total against that state's dollar and transaction thresholds, including or excluding marketplace sales per that state's rule.
Register before you collect
Apply for a sales-tax permit in each state where you have nexus. Collecting tax without a valid permit is itself a violation — register first, then turn on collection.
Configure taxability
Determine whether your products or services are taxable in each state (some exempt groceries, clothing, or SaaS), and set the correct rate down to the local level, since many states have county and city add-ons.
Collect and remit on schedule
Charge the right rate at checkout, then file and remit on each state's assigned frequency — monthly, quarterly, or annually depending on your volume.
Clean up back periods with a VDA
If you already have unregistered nexus, a voluntary disclosure agreement typically caps the look-back period and waives penalties versus waiting for the state to assess you.
Don't forget the one filing everyone hates: many states require a return even for periods with zero taxable sales once you're registered. Missing a "zero return" still generates a late-filing penalty and can put your permit in bad standing. Set a recurring reminder for every state's due date the moment you register, whether or not you expect tax due that period.
What non-compliance actually costs
The defining feature of sales-tax exposure is that the tax you failed to collect becomes your liability. You can't go back and bill customers for a purchase they made two years ago, so the assessment comes out of your margin — plus penalties and interest that compound for every open period.
- Personal business liability for tax you never collected from customers
- Late-filing and late-payment penalties stacked on every open period
- Interest accruing from each original due date until paid
- No statute of limitations on unfiled returns — exposure stays open indefinitely
- Loss of voluntary-disclosure benefits if the state contacts you first
- Complications in a future sale of the business, where buyers demand clean sales-tax history in due diligence
Wayfair made sales volume — not physical presence — the trigger for sales-tax collection, and nearly every state now enforces its own thresholds. Track your sales by ship-to state, test each running total against that state's specific dollar and transaction rules, and remember that marketplace sales usually count toward the threshold even when the platform collects the tax. Register before you collect, file every period including zero returns, and use a voluntary disclosure agreement to close back years before a state finds you. Uncollected sales tax is your liability, and unfiled returns never expire — which makes early, deliberate compliance far cheaper than the cleanup.
Know exactly where you owe sales tax
SMAART Tax measures your economic-nexus footprint across every state, handles registrations, sets up collection, and negotiates voluntary disclosures to close open periods — before an assessment lands on your margin.
Talk to a tax proSources
- U.S. Supreme Court — South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., 585 U.S. ___ (2018)
- South Dakota Codified Laws § 10-64-2 (the $100,000 / 200-transaction threshold upheld in Wayfair)
- U.S. Supreme Court — Quill Corp. v. North Dakota, 504 U.S. 298 (1992) (overturned by Wayfair)
- Streamlined Sales Tax Governing Board — Remote Seller and Marketplace Facilitator resources
- IRS / State Departments of Revenue — Marketplace Facilitator and Remote Seller registration guidance
Frequently asked questions
Economic nexus means a state can require you to collect and remit its sales tax based on your sales volume into the state alone — no physical presence required. It was made possible by the Supreme Court's 2018 South Dakota v. Wayfair decision, which overturned the old physical-presence rule.
The most widely used threshold is $100,000 in sales OR 200 separate transactions into a state in the current or prior year. But thresholds vary: some states use $500,000, some dropped the 200-transaction test entirely, and each measures the period differently. You must check each state where you sell.
Usually the marketplace collects and remits for you under marketplace-facilitator laws, so you don't collect on those sales. But those sales may still count toward your economic-nexus threshold, and any sales you make through your own website or other channels are your responsibility to track and remit.
You become personally liable for the uncollected tax — the state can assess it against your business even though you never charged your customers — plus penalties and interest for every open period. Because unfiled sales-tax returns keep the statute of limitations open, the exposure grows until you register and file, often through a voluntary disclosure agreement.






